Reply to this topic
If there is a guy and a girl, teenagers, who reeally like each other.
they didn't plan to but they had intercourse.. are they allowed to kill the baby?
And also what are the punishments of this?
0
BIG problem..
Started by Guest_worried_*, Jun 29 2011 08:17 AM
16 replies to this topic
#3
-
- Brothers
-
- 2,918 posts
Formerly 'AMIR'
- Gender:Not Telling
Posted 29 June 2011 - 07:05 PM
worried, on 29 June 2011 - 08:17 AM, said:
If there is a guy and a girl, teenagers, who reeally like each other.
they didn't plan to but they had intercourse.. are they allowed to kill the baby?
And also what are the punishments of this?
they didn't plan to but they had intercourse.. are they allowed to kill the baby?
And also what are the punishments of this?
Kill the baby after birth, or do you mean abortion?
#4
-
- Brothers
-
- 15,363 posts
Official Rebel Leader of BoB
- Gender:Male
- Location:Muslim Capital of Europe
Posted 29 June 2011 - 08:39 PM
the punnishment is the baby is given birth bought up by the mother and when the child reaches a certain age the parents go through death penalty not the child who should be aborted, hadith regarding this matter, couldnt find the hadith so posted the commentry below.
Imam al-Nawawi (may Allah's Mercy be upon him) said in his comments on Sahih Muslim concerning al-Ghamidiyah (a woman committed Zina): 'The Prophetic expression "Until you give birth" indicates that a pregnant should not be stoned before giving birth. Also, an unmarried woman should not be lashed before giving birth. There is agreement among scholars on this point. Then, she (a pregnant woman) should not be punished until she suckles her child or he/she becomes satisfied with some women's suckling' .
But since khilafah doesnt exist, this cannot be done, what the best opinion here is to best check what a scholar says, islam qa is a good plae to go and check on this matter.
Imam al-Nawawi (may Allah's Mercy be upon him) said in his comments on Sahih Muslim concerning al-Ghamidiyah (a woman committed Zina): 'The Prophetic expression "Until you give birth" indicates that a pregnant should not be stoned before giving birth. Also, an unmarried woman should not be lashed before giving birth. There is agreement among scholars on this point. Then, she (a pregnant woman) should not be punished until she suckles her child or he/she becomes satisfied with some women's suckling' .
But since khilafah doesnt exist, this cannot be done, what the best opinion here is to best check what a scholar says, islam qa is a good plae to go and check on this matter.
#8 Guest_Wafa_*
-
- Guests
Posted 30 June 2011 - 03:14 AM
anon, on 29 June 2011 - 09:47 PM, said:
so they are not allowed to take the pills, for sure? even though they are really young & have school etc..
yes i meant abortion
yes i meant abortion
Reality Check: No one cares if you have school or how young you are. Should have thought of that before you decide to pull down your pants. This is a serious matter. You thought you were responsible enough to have sex well then be responsible enough to handle the consequences. Act like a man or a woman and do what you need to do that doesn't involve screwing over an unborn child. Abortion is serious: not a convenient option to clean up after yourself.
In America, if you are under 18 you need parental consent for an abortion. I am not sure how it works in other countries but they are likely to have something similar. I doubt they simply let anybody, at any age walk in and get it over with. So if your intention is to hide a pregnancy, then you may want to reevaluate that plan.
If anyone is in fact pregnant in this situation, then your best option is to bite the bullet and no matter how scared you may be right now, you absolutely need to talk to your parents. After much screaming and possibly nailing your behind to the wall, they might come around and accept the child.
In any case, your reputation will definitely get tarnished but that just comes with the package. Hold your head up high and forget about everybody else. This is between you, Allah and your partner. Going through social, parental execution is far more superior than committing murder.
#9
-
- Brothers
-
- 4,309 posts
Comet
- Gender:Male
Posted 30 June 2011 - 07:54 AM
worried, on 29 June 2011 - 08:17 AM, said:
If there is a guy and a girl, teenagers, who reeally like each other.
they didn't plan to but they had intercourse.. are they allowed to kill the baby?
And also what are the punishments of this?
they didn't plan to but they had intercourse.. are they allowed to kill the baby?
And also what are the punishments of this?
Everyone makes mistakes, and people do sin.
The important fact is that you repent and then deal with it in the right way inshAllah.
For whoever this is, it is important that they take care of the child. The child is real, and even if you think you are young it is still a human being. It is your family, and brave what you must to be with that child.
InshAllah, this child becomes a way for you to earn forgiveness for mistakes that have been made =).
And don't be scared, support always comes! Parents, even if they do get upset, will still try to support their children generally. May Allah make it easy for you!
Reply to this topic
1 user(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users
